Management situations at Wells Fargo Bank
Describe how the organization was managed in the past. Compare the difference between management approaches in the past to those the organization currently uses. Ensure you identify relevant management theory both for past practices and current approaches.
Describe how the organization is structured. Include a copy of the organizational chart. Describe how managers perform the organization function of management based on the structure of the organization. Ensure one of the five types of structures as described in the textbook is identified and analyzed.
Identify a key manager in the organization and describe his/her primary functions and responsibilities. Evaluate how effective this manager is in fulfilling these responsibilities making clear recommendations for improvement. Ensure you refer to the functions of management as described in your textbook.
Describe how decisions are made in this organization. Using materials from the textbook or other relevant sources on decision making evaluate the effectiveness of the decision making process and make clear recommendations for improvement.
Describe the system of controls the organization uses. Include in this description how control is used to ensure the organization meets its goals and objectives as well as how the organization uses a quality control process to ensure products and/or services are delivered as promised. Evaluate the role of managers in these processes. Make clear recommendations for improvement. Ensure you refer to your textbook or other relevant sources in your evaluation.
Management situations at Wells Fargo Bank
In this paper, the functions of planning, organizing and controlling are applied. The current management situations at Wells Fargo Bank are examined comprehensively. How Wells Fargo was managed in the past and how it is currently structured is described. The primary responsibilities and functions of a key manager are described. Furthermore, the paper describes how decisions are made in this bank. The system of control used by Wells Fargo is also described and appropriate recommendations are made identifying each with the pertinent management function.
Past management approach: System approach
In the past, the management of Wells Fargo employed the system approach. Using this approach, the organization is viewed as an open and organic system that comprises interdependent and interacting components known as sub-systems. This past management approach is rooted in the generalization that all things are inter-reliant and interconnected (Kast & Rosenzweig, 2010). A system comprises reliant and related parts which, when in interaction, create a unitary whole (Daft, 2015). A system is basically a combination or assemblage of components or things creating a composite whole. The system comprises hierarchy of sub-systems.
Comparison of management approaches
At the moment, the management approach being utilized at Wells Fargo is the contingency approach also referred to as the situational approach. The top executives at this financial company realized that under different situations, management problems are different hence they have to be dealt with according to the demand of the situation. The contingency approach differs from the previously used system approach in that the contingency approach seeks to integrate theory with practice in systems framework (Kast & Rosenzweig, 2010). The organization’s behaviour is considered as being dependent on the environmental forces. Unlike the systems approach, the contingency approach supposes that the behaviour of any single subunit depends upon its environment as well as its association with other sub-units or units which have control over the sequences that are desired by that particular sub-unit.
Manager’s performance of functions of management based on organization structure
At Wells Fargo Bank, the organization structure adopted by the company is matrix structure. This organization structure is basically a combination of at least 2 kinds of organization structure, for instance the functional organization structure and the divisional structure. In the matrix organization structure, the functional manager’s authority flows vertically and the divisional manager’s authority flows sideways (Swarnalatha & Vasantham, 2014). The matrix organization structure at Wells Fargo creates power struggles given that many areas of the organization have a dual management – a divisional and a functional manager who work at the same level and more or less the same managerial territory.
A key manager: primary functions and responsibilities
At Wells Fargo Bank, one key manager is the company’s Customer Service Manager for Greater Los Angeles Area, Shelly Hisel. In his role, he is in charge of several customer service representatives who work face-to-face, live chat, over email, or call centres. He helps in building good customer relations. He arranges meetings of employees. He recruits staffs and carries out assessments, and handles queries and complaints from both employees and clients.
Effectiveness of manager in fulfilling this role
In fulfilling his roles at Wells Fargo Bank, Shelly Hisen has not carried out his functions very effectively. He has properly resolved problems between workmates and established ground rules and expectations. However, he has not been very effective in following guidelines of the firm for dealing with clients and resolving problems from clients as they crop up. He has not handled queries and complaints from clients in an adequate and proper manner. A case in point, when Wells Fargo bank faced an unethical issue by treating its clients in an unethical manner for instance by forging signatures of clients and charging fees on accounts of clients who are unaware, Shelly Hisen disregarded many customer complaints and did not resolve customer complaints satisfactorily or properly.
Recommendations for improvement
To improve on his roles as a customer service manager, Shelly Hisel should lead and motivate his team of Wells Fargo employees to make sure that they actually give the most excellent customer service possible. He should also communicate the company’s policies and products to other staff members at this firm (Daft, 2015). As the company’s customer service manager, Shelly Hisen should ensure that his team actually does its best in meeting the needs of clients by providing useful tips on a product and troubleshooting problems. He can also make recommendations on ways of resolving customer issues.
How decisions are made
At Wells Fargo Bank, decisions are made using the political model. Managers at this firm usually engage in coalition building for making decisions that are complex. It is worth mentioning that a coalition is essentially an informal alliance amongst managers who support a particular common objective (Daft, 2015). Various managers form alliances in coalition building process. If there is no coalition, a powerful group or person in the company can disrupt the process of decision-making.
Effectiveness of the decision making process
The decision making process using the political model at Wells Fargo is for the most part effective. Coalition building provides many managers in this company a chance of contributing to the process of decision making, which serves to enhance their commitment to the alternative which is adopted in the end. This political model has particularly been effective at Wells Fargo for making non-programmed decisions when there is little information and conditions are uncertain (Daft, 2015). It is also very useful when there are conflicts amongst managers regarding which goals the company needs to pursue or which course of action should be taken.
Recommendations for improvement
In order to improve the process of decision-making at Wells Fargo bank, it is recommended that the key managers at this company should at times adopt the classical model or the administrative model of decision making. For instance, the classical model of decision is most practical whenever it is applied to programmed decisions. It also useful in decisions which are typified by risk or certainty given that pertinent information is available and it is possible to calculate probabilities (Daft, 2015). Effective managers at Wells Fargo can also utilize a mix of intuition and rational analysis to make difficult decisions under the pressure of time. Intuition, which is a vital part of administrative decision making, plays a more and more crucial role in decision-making.
System of control the organization uses
Organizational control is basically understood as the systematic process that is used to regulate activities in an organization in order to make them at one with the expectations established in targets, plans as well as standards of performance (Silva Gonçalves, 2010). At Wells Fargo, the system of control used is the Balanced Scorecard. This approach takes a balanced perspective on the performance of the organization and integrates different aspects of control which focus on clients and markets, in addition to financials and staff members. This system of control is comprehensive.
Recommendations for improvement
In order to improve organizational control at Wells Fargo, it is recommended that the company’s management combine the Balanced Scorecard approach with other approaches to organizational control such as the Feedback Control Model and the Total Quality Management (TQM) philosophy. Using the 4 steps of feedback control, managers at Wells Fargo should establish control systems which comprise 4 main steps: creating standards, measuring performance, comparing performance to standards, and making necessary corrections (Daft, 2015). By using TQM techniques, Wells Fargo would make a company-wide effort aimed at infusing quality into all activities within the firm by way of continuous improvement (Silva Gonçalves, 2010). These two approaches should not replace the current Balanced Scorecard approach, but should rather be used together with the balanced scorecard. This would help to improve organizational control at Wells Fargo.
Summary of key recommendations
A summary of the key recommendations made in the three sections above are as follows. First, for Wells Fargo’s customer service manager Shelly Hisen to improve on his roles, he has to lead and motivate his team to make sure that they really give the finest customer service possible. Secondly, to improve the process of decision-making at this financial institution, it is recommended that the key managers at this firm should sometimes adopt the classical model or the administrative model of decision making whenever necessary. To improve organizational control, it is recommended that the senior management at Wells Fargo combine the Balanced Scorecard approach with other approaches to organizational control including the Feedback Control Model and Total Quality Management techniques.
In conclusion, the present management situations at Wells Fargo Bank have been described in this paper exhaustively. In the past, Wells Fargo was managed using the classical management approach and its current organization structure is matrix. One of the key managers, the Customer Service Manager, helps in building good customer relations and he arranges meetings of employees. He also handles queries and complaints from both employees and clients. Decisions are made in this bank using the political model. Furthermore, the system of control used by Wells Fargo is the Balanced Scorecard.
Daft, R. L. (2015). Management (10th ed). Columbus, OH: South-Western College.
Kast, F. E., & Rosenzweig, J. E. (2010). Organization and management: A systems and contingency approach (3d ed.). New York: McGraw-Hill
Pimentel, L., & Major, M. J. (2014). Quality management and a balanced scorecard as supporting frameworks for a new management model and organisational change. Total Quality Management & Business Excellence, 25(7-8), 763-775.
Silva Gonçalves, H. (2010). Proposal of a strategy model planning aligned to the balanced scorecard and the quality environments. The TQM Journal, 21(5), 462-472.
Swarnalatha, C., & Vasantham, S. T. (2014). Organization structure-an overview. Indian Streams Research Journal, 4(6), 1-3.