Ethical Debate of the Internet on the Information Privacy
We live in a world where the internet plays a pinnacle role in our day to day lives. Discuss how the
internet has caused an ethical debate on our information privacy
Introduction
Currently, people live in a world where the internet plays a major role in day-to-day lives,
commonly referred to as the information age, which can be described as an era where economic
activities are mainly based on information. This comes as a result of the development and use of
technology. This article discusses the ethical questions related to the right to privacy of an
individual that is threatened by the use of the internet. Specifically, it gives the challenges that
ETHICAL DEBATE OF THE INTERNET ON THE INFORMATION PRIVACY 2
these ethical problems pose to the information professional and the practical guidelines based on
the ethical norms.
The Concept of Privacy and Ethics
Privacy is defined as a condition of life of an individual that is characterized by an
exclusion from the public. This concept follows the right to be left all alone (Thierer, 2013).
Such a privacy perception sets the course for passing the laws of privacy in the United States for
the following years. Privacy could be regarded as a right that provides the foundation for the
legal right. This is important because it is necessary for the fulfillment of other rights such as
freedom and the personal autonomy, which are quite related. The respect of someone’s privacy
acknowledges the person’s rights to freedom and recognizes that the person is an autonomous
human being. Thus, respecting a person’s privacy is a duty that everyone is obliged to follow.
Categories of Private Information
According to Kauffman, Lee, Prosch, and Steinbart, (2011), privacy is usually expressed
by means of information. This implies that it is possible to categorize privacy, namely;
information that is related to the privacy of an individual’s body, private communications,
information regarding a person’s possessions and other personal information.
The category of private communications concerns all the forms of personal
communication, which one wishes to keep private. This kind of information is usually
exchanged, for example, between the user and informational professional during a reference
interview. The category of the privacy of the body normally refers to the medical information
and enjoys a separate legal protection (Kauffman, Lee, Prosch, & Steinbart, 2011). This
ETHICAL DEBATE OF THE INTERNET ON THE INFORMATION PRIVACY 3
legislation defines the right of a person to be notified about the nature of an illness and the
implications associated with it.
The category of personal information refers only to the information of a specific person.
Examples of these kinds of information include name, address, which are the bibliographic data,
and the financial information. All of these are relevant to the categories of the information
professionals. Lastly, the category of the information about someone’s possession is known to be
closely related to the right to own property (Thierer, 2013). A person has the right to control the
information, which relates to his personal possessions in certain instances. A good example of
this is the secrecy about the place where a person has kept his wallet.
Ethics
Ethical actions of a person are described as those actions, which are performed within the
criteria of what is regarded as right. In terms of human actions, it relates to the question of what
is good or bad. Its purpose is to help people behave in an honorable manner and attain the basic
good that make them fully human.
The Influence of the Internet on the Processing of Personal and Private Information
Definition of the Internet in relation to Information Technology
According to Busch (2013), the concept of technology is defined as the process of
gathering, organizing, storing and distributing information in different formats by the use of
computer means and the techniques based on the micro-electronics. He defines internet as a form
of technology that is a network of many computers, which he sometimes calls the Global
Information Infrastructure (GII) (Busch, 2013).
ETHICAL DEBATE OF THE INTERNET ON THE INFORMATION PRIVACY 4
Ethical Implications for the Use of Technology in Processing Information
The main ethical impact of technology relates to accessibility and inaccessibility and the
handling or manipulation of information. Through its implications, it becomes easy to access the
private information of an individual by many people. Other than that, the person may be
excluded from necessary information in the electronic format by use of security formats such as
passwords. This kind of manipulation of information by the use of technology refers to the
integration of information done by the merging of documents, repackaging of information, which
involves the translations and the integration of textual and the graphical formats, and the
alteration of information by the means of computer electronics, thus, changing the photographic
images.
The use of technology to process information is not regarded as ethically neutral.
Technology has, however, changed the ontological status of a document while accompanying the
ethical implications (Mingers & Walsham, 2010). This refers to the manipulation of personal
information by the use of the internet as a form of technology.
The impact of technology use on the private lives of people manifests itself in a variety of
areas. First, is the use of the electronic monitoring of people in the workplace. Research shows
that companies justify their use of technology to the increase of their productivity. However,
there are several ethical problems pertaining to it (Nunan & Di, 2013). People’s privacy in their
workplaces are threatened by these devices, which could lead to fear and the panoptical
phenomenon. Second is the interception and the access to the email messages of people. This is
an ethical problem related to the private communication of a person. The reading of email
messages is justified at workplaces because they get to see the technology infrastructure as
ETHICAL DEBATE OF THE INTERNET ON THE INFORMATION PRIVACY 5
usually a resource being to the company rather not to an individual. Aside from that, they get to
intercept the messages so as to get to know whether their employees use the facilities for their
own private and selfish reasons or for the right purposes of the job.
Thirdly, there is the merging of databases, which contain the private information known
as the data banking (Nunan & Di, 2013). This shows the integration of personal information
from various databases into one central database. The problem here comes up because the
individual is not aware of his personal information that is being integrated in the central
database, the purposes for that, and if truly the information gathered is accurate. Forth, is the
buying of cards by the retail stores. These cards are buried with computer chips that record every
item that is purchased together with the variety of information of the buyer which allows
companies to do targeted marketing to people they may have known their personal information
and their buying habits (Busch, 2013). Lastly, another threat to information privacy is the
increase in the number of hackers and crackers, which break into the computer systems
(Kauffman, Lee, Prosch, & Steinbart, 2011). This comes together with the shift in the ethical
values as well as the emergence of the culture of the cyberpunk with the ‘information wants to be
free’ motto.
Associated Effect
The use of technology affects the individual level in that it causes loss of dignity and
spontaneity as well as a threat to the right of information privacy and freedom. Technology is
viewed more as a cause of threat rather than personal freedom. Research conducted by one of the
biggest credit bureau companies in the USA, Equifax, showed that approximately 79% of the
ETHICAL DEBATE OF THE INTERNET ON THE INFORMATION PRIVACY 6
respondents indicated that they were weary of the use of technology for the processing of
personal information (Nunan & Di, 2013).
Technology also has effects on the economic and the social levels. The biggest effect is
the growth of businesses such as the credit bureau and the telecommunication companies that
specializes in the processing and trade of person related information. The legislation on the
protection of information privacy on the internet of an individual is known to fall behind due to
the rapidly changing world in terms of technology (Thierer, 2013).
Relevance to the Information Professional
Ethical Issues
Handling and processing of the categories of personal and private information is entitled
with several ethical issues. First is the confidential treatment of such information which refers to
the information that is gained from the reference interview. The main ethical problems regarding
this could be the use of personal details obtained from the interview for other purposes rather
than what they were gathered for. This involves the re-use of a search strategy of one user for
another user and discussing the nature of the specific query with other people.
Second is the issue of accuracy of information, which is important in cases where an
information professional is working with the personal information that could have a direct
influence to a person’s life. Third is the purpose for using different categories of information.
The question is whether an information professional will employ the categories of private
information for other reasons other than the original reason and whether the person should be
informed about it (Mingers & Walsham, 2010).
ETHICAL DEBATE OF THE INTERNET ON THE INFORMATION PRIVACY 7
Last is the ethical problem of the rights of a person in the use and distribution of his or
her personal information. The related questions to this is if the user has the right to verify the
information held by the professional and what rights the person has regarding the correction of
any wrong information. Other than that, it is necessary to question if the person has the right to
know the person using his personal information and for what reasons.
Ethical Norms
It is necessary to formulate the ethical norms to address the ethical issues. The ethical
norms that can be distinguished are freedom, truth and the human right. Truth has a dual
application in ethics. It is a norm for factual correctness of information. It thus guides the
information professional to accurately and correctly handle the private information of an
individual.
An individual also has the freedom to make choices in terms of the freedom of privacy
and the freedom from intrusion though it may not become absolutized. The human rights norm
on the other hand means the juridical acknowledgement and protection of the right to privacy of
a person. It protects an individual from the unlawful interference from the society in the private
life of an individual.
Ethical Guidelines
The recognition of person’s autonomy and freedom together with the fact that the
guidelines on information privacy do not give a complete framework for ethical actions of the
information professional regarding handling an individual’s private information. Thus, it is
important to have the following ethical guidelines in mind.
ETHICAL DEBATE OF THE INTERNET ON THE INFORMATION PRIVACY 8
The information professional is required to act on the assumption that is regarded by the
client as confidential. This implies that the information professional is obliged to acknowledge
the right of the client to control any private information. Regularly, the client is obliged to have
access to all the private and personal information that is used by the information professional.
This helps the client to have the opportunity to verify if the information is accurate.
Merging of personal information of an individual into a different database should be done
with necessary caution. This is applicable in certain situations where the client is not aware of
the merging or rather its implications. The client should be informed about that and be given the
right to access the information in the central database. Other than that, the client should be given
the right to change the information in the central database if it could by any chance be incorrect.
In addition it is the right of the client to know those people using the information and for what
purposes.
It is necessary for the information professional to notify the client of any intended
purpose of using the information. This implies that the client has granted permission to that. No
unnecessary private information should be gathered. This is for both the logistics reasons and to
prevent any unnecessary violation of the person’s information privacy. Aside from that, any
personal information that is collected and is no longer necessary should be destroyed (Bush,
2013). This is based on the norms of freedom and the human rights. In addition, in case the
rendering of a specific product or service is refused to an individual due to his or her personal
information like the credit worthiness, it is necessary to inform the individual the reason for
denial. This is based on the norm of truth and the human rights. Personal information must be
given strict confidentiality. This is the security and the control of information regarding the right
to access it and the right to change and add any necessary information to it (Thierer, 2013).
ETHICAL DEBATE OF THE INTERNET ON THE INFORMATION PRIVACY 9
Conclusion
In conclusion, the use of the internet in processing information has various important
questions with regard to a person’s right to information privacy, which is directly linked to the
freedom right and the human autonomy. These problems relate to the accessibility and the
manipulation of information. It is, however, relevant to the information professional who deals
with the private and the personal information. Their practical guidelines to handle the problems
are formulated according to the truth, norms of freedom, and the human rights. In a world that is
facing a rapid technological advancement, it is important that relevant sectors take appropriate
measures to curb cases of cyber-crime, in order to protect the rights of users and ensure complete
confidentiality. Otherwise, this piece of unprecedented innovation might as well become its own
barrier.
References
Busch, T. (2013). Fair Information Technologies. The Corporate Responsibility of Online Social
Networks as Public Regulators. University Of St. Gallen, Business Dissertations, 1-158.
ETHICAL DEBATE OF THE INTERNET ON THE INFORMATION PRIVACY 10
Kauffman, R. J., Lee, Y. J., Prosch, M., & Steinbart, P. J. (2011). A Survey of Consumer
Information Privacy from the Accounting Information Systems Perspective. Journal Of
Information Systems, 25(2), 47-79.
Mingers, J., & Walsham, G. (2010). Toward Ethical Information Systems: The Contribution of
Discourse Ethics. MIS Quarterly, 34(4), 833-854.
Nunan, D., & Di Domenico, M. (2013). Market research and the ethics of big data. International
Journal Of Market Research, 55(4), 2-13.
Thierer, A. (2013). The Pursuit Of Privacy In A World Where Information Control Is Failing.
Harvard Journal Of Law & Public Policy, 36(2), 409-455.
